10 Red Flags of Bad Service Providers in Costa Rica (And How to Find Reliable Ones

The gardener who shows up three times then disappears.

The pool guy who charges double what the neighbors pay.

The housekeeper with "emergency family situations" every other week.

The contractor whose "two-week project" enters month four with no end in sight.

If you're an expat homeowner in Costa Rica, you've either experienced this nightmare yourself or heard horror stories from other expats at the weekly coffee meetup.

After years of managing luxury properties for British Embassy diplomats and helping expat seniors maintain their homes in Costa Rica, I've seen every type of bad service provider imaginable — and learned exactly how to spot them before they become your problem.

Today, I'm sharing the 10 biggest red flags that scream "run away" and, more importantly, the proven system for finding providers you can actually trust.

Because your Costa Rica dream shouldn't include dealing with unreliable contractors, overpriced services, or watching your property slowly deteriorate because nobody shows up when they say they will.

Why Finding Good Service Providers in Costa Rica Is So Hard

Before we dive into the red flags, let's talk about why this is such a common problem for expats — especially those living alone or managing properties from abroad.

The Language Barrier Creates Vulnerability

When you can't fully communicate in Spanish, you're at a disadvantage from day one. Bad providers know this. They:

• Quote prices in rapid-fire Spanish and hope you nod along

• Skip explaining what's actually included in the service

• Change scope mid-project because "you said it was okay"

• Blame communication issues when problems arise

The reality: many expats overpay for services simply because they can't negotiate effectively or don't know what questions to ask.

The "Gringo Price" Is Real

Let's be blunt: some providers charge foreigners 2-3 times what they charge Costa Ricans for the exact same work. They see an American or Canadian homeowner and think "easy money."

This isn't every provider — but it happens often enough that you need to be aware.

Cultural Differences in Business Practices

In Costa Rica, business relationships often operate differently than in North America:

• Written contracts are less common for small services

• "Tico time" means deadlines are flexible suggestions

• Personal connections matter more than professional credentials

• Saying "yes" is polite, even if the answer is really "maybe"

Understanding these cultural differences doesn't excuse bad service — but it helps you spot genuine issues versus cultural misunderstandings.

Property Owners Are Easy Targets

Bad service providers specifically target:

• Absentee owners who only visit a few times per year

• New expats who don't know fair prices or reliable providers

• Seniors living alone who may be vulnerable or trusting

• Non-Spanish speakers who can't verify information

If you check any of these boxes, you're at higher risk — and need to be extra careful about who you hire.

The 10 Biggest Red Flags of Bad Service Providers in Costa Rica

Here's what to watch for. Even one or two of these should make you pause. Three or more? Walk away immediately.

Red Flag #1: No Verifiable References

What it looks like:

• "All my clients moved back to the States"

• Gives you phone numbers that don't answer

• References are vague: "Ask anyone in town"

Why it's a problem: Reliable domestic workers and contractors in Costa Rica have a trail of satisfied clients. If someone can't provide 2-3 current references with working phone numbers, that's a massive red flag.

Real story from my files: An expat couple in Tamarindo hired a "highly recommended" contractor to renovate their bathroom. When I asked which neighbors recommended him, they said "Oh, we found him on Facebook." No references checked. Three months and $8,000 later, the bathroom still leaked, tiles were crooked, and the contractor stopped answering calls.

What to do instead: Demand at least 3 references from current clients. Call them. Ask:

• How long have they worked for you?

• Do they show up consistently?

• Have there been any problems?

• Would you hire them again?

Red Flag #2: Requests for Large Upfront Payments

What it looks like:

• "I need 100% payment before I start"

• "Pay for all materials upfront"

• Wants cash only, no receipt

• Pressures you to pay immediately "or the price goes up"

Why it's a problem: Once they have your money, you have zero leverage. Costa Rican labor laws protect workers, but they don't protect you from contractors who disappear with your deposit.

Standard payment structure in Costa Rica:

• Materials: 50% upfront max (with receipts)

• Labor: Progress payments tied to milestones

• Final 20-30%: Held until job is completed satisfactorily

Real story: Margaret in Nosara paid a pool company ₡2,000,000 ($4,000) upfront for repairs. They came twice, left equipment in her yard, and vanished. When she finally tracked them down, they claimed the work was "90% complete." It wasn't. She never got her money back.

Red Flag #3: No Legal Documentation

What it looks like:

• Won't provide Cédula (Costa Rican ID)

• No business license or permits

• Not registered with CAJA social security

• Can't provide insurance certificates

Why it's a problem: If an uninsured, unregistered worker gets injured on your property, YOU are liable. Costa Rican law requires workers to be registered with CAJA and have workers' compensation insurance.

What you need to verify:

• Copy of Cédula (ID card)

• CAJA registration if hiring as employee

• If independent contractor: proof of trabajador independiente status

• Workers' compensation insurance (from INS)

Exception: Many excellent independent contractors work informally. But YOU need to decide if you're willing to assume the legal risk. I generally don't recommend it for expats unfamiliar with Costa Rican labor law.

Red Flag #4: Inconsistent or No-Show Behavior

What it looks like:

• Cancels the day-of repeatedly

• "Emergency" excuses every other week

• Shows up hours late without notice

• Works for an hour, leaves, doesn't return

Why it's a problem: Property maintenance in Costa Rica's climate is time-sensitive. A small leak becomes major water damage. Overgrown gardens attract snakes. Pool chemistry issues can cost thousands.

Costa Rica context: Yes, "Tico time" is a thing. Traffic is terrible. Unexpected things happen. But reliable providers will:

• Give advance notice when they can't make it

• Suggest alternative times immediately

• Show up within 30 minutes of agreed time

• Communicate proactively

What to do:

• First no-show: Give benefit of the doubt

• Second no-show: Warning conversation

• Third no-show: Find someone else

Red Flag #5: Vague Pricing or Changing Quotes

What it looks like:

• "We'll figure out the price as we go"

• Written quote doesn't match verbal quote

• Adds charges mid-project without discussion

• Bills for "extras" that were clearly part of original scope

Why it's a problem: You need to budget. Surprises are stressful. And constantly changing prices are often a tactic to extract more money from confused clients.

What fair pricing looks like:

• Hourly work: Clear hourly rate in writing

• Projects: Itemized quote with labor and materials separate

• Change orders: Discussed and agreed upon BEFORE work proceeds

• Payment terms: Specified upfront

Red flag phrases:

• "Don't worry about the cost"

• "We'll work it out"

• "Trust me, it's fair"

Red Flag #6: Pressures You to Decide Immediately

What it looks like:

• "This price is only good today"

• "I have another client who wants this time slot"

• Gets defensive when you say you need to think about it

• "Don't you trust me?"

Why it's a problem: Legitimate providers are busy but not desperate. Pressure tactics are what scammers use because they know their offer won't hold up to scrutiny.

What good providers do:

• Give you a written quote to review

• Encourage you to get other estimates

• Answer questions patiently

• Follow up professionally

My rule: Any provider who pressures immediate decisions without letting you think, consult, or compare automatically disqualifies themselves.

Red Flag #7: Poor Communication or Language Barriers They Won't Address

What it looks like:

• Gets frustrated when you ask questions

• Won't slow down or use simpler Spanish

• Refuses to write things down

• No attempt to use translator apps or bring someone bilingual

Why it's a problem: If you can't communicate clearly about expectations, timeline, price, and quality standards, you're headed for conflict and disappointment.

Good providers working with expats:

• Speak at least some English, or

• Bring a bilingual helper, or

• Use WhatsApp translator, or

• Write everything down with numbers/diagrams

Real example: I accompanied a client to meet a contractor. The contractor spoke zero English. My client spoke limited Spanish. The contractor got irritated when we asked clarifying questions and said "Ya sabe" (you already know) repeatedly. We left. That attitude would've been disaster.

Red Flag #8: Unwilling to Provide Written Agreements

What it looks like:

• "We don't need a contract, we trust each other"

• "I don't do paperwork"

• Gets defensive when you request written terms

• "That's not how we do things here"

Why it's a problem: Written agreements protect BOTH parties. A provider who refuses documentation is either:

• Planning to change terms later

• Hiding something (tax status, insurance, etc.)

• Unprofessional

What you need in writing (even if simple):

• Scope of work

• Timeline

• Price and payment schedule

• Contact information

• Start and completion dates

Costa Rica note: Many small services operate on handshake agreements. That's fine for a one-time $50 gardening session. But for anything over $1000 or ongoing arrangements? Get it in writing.

Red Flag #9: Badmouths Previous Clients or Other Providers

What it looks like:

• "My last client was crazy"

• "All other gardeners/contractors in the area are incompetent"

• "Expats don't understand how things work here"

• Shares gossip about other clients

Why it's a problem: Professional providers don't trash-talk. Period.

If they gossip about previous clients to you, they'll gossip about you to the next client. And if everyone else is "terrible," the common denominator is probably them.

What good providers say:

• "That wasn't a good fit"

• "We had different expectations"

• "I respect other providers even if we work differently"

Red Flag #10: Makes Excuses Instead of Solving Problems

What it looks like:

• Blames everyone else when things go wrong

• "It's not my fault the materials didn't arrive"

• "You didn't explain it correctly"

• More time spent justifying than fixing

Why it's a problem: Things go wrong in every project. The difference between good and bad providers is how they respond.

Good providers:

• Acknowledge issues quickly

• Propose solutions immediately

• Take responsibility even when it's not entirely their fault

• Fix problems before arguing about who's to blame

Example: A good gardener discovers your irrigation system is broken. They tell you immediately, give you options, and offer to either fix it or recommend someone who can. A bad gardener lets your plants die, then says "You should have checked the system."

How to Find Reliable Service Providers in Costa Rica: The Expat-Tested Method

Now that you know what to avoid, here's the proven system for finding providers you can trust.

Step 1: Start with Trusted Referrals

Best sources (in order):

1. Your neighbors — Especially if they're long-term residents

2. Local expat Facebook groups — But verify everything yourself

3. Your property manager or realtor — They know who's reliable

4. Other expats at community events — Ask specific questions

Questions to ask when getting referrals:

• How long have you used them?

• Any problems or surprises?

• Do they show up consistently?

• Fair pricing?

• Would you hire them again?

Step 2: Conduct a Proper Vetting Process

Don't skip these steps:

Initial phone/WhatsApp screening:

• Do they respond promptly?

• Can you communicate effectively?

• Do they ask intelligent questions about the job?

In-person meeting:

• Do they show up on time?

• Do they inspect the work area thoroughly?

• Do they take notes or measurements?

Written quote:

• Itemized with materials and labor separate?

• Timeline specified?

• Payment terms clear?

Reference checks:

• Call at least 2 references

• Visit a current job site if possible

Step 3: Start Small

Even with referrals and vetting, start with a small project or trial period:

For household staff:

• Hire for one day initially

• Graduate to weekly, then regular schedule

• Formal employment contract only after 2-3 months

For contractors:

• Small repair before large renovation

• One-time service before ongoing contract

For gardeners/pool service:

• Month-to-month before committing to longer terms

This protects you if red flags emerge that didn't show up in vetting.

Step 4: Establish Clear Expectations in Writing

Even for simple services, write down:

• What exactly will be done

• When it will be done

• How much it costs

• How they'll be paid

• How to handle problems

Use WhatsApp to send written confirmation of verbal agreements. Screenshots are your friend.

Step 5: Monitor and Document Everything

For ongoing services:

• Take photos before and after

• Keep written logs of when they worked

• Save all receipts and invoices

• Document any issues immediately

Why this matters: If you need to let someone go or dispute charges, documentation is essential. Costa Rican labor law is worker-friendly, so paper trails protect you.

Fair Pricing Guide: What You Should Actually Pay in Costa Rica (2025)

One of the biggest challenges is knowing if you're being overcharged. Here are current fair market rates:

Household Services

Service	Fair Rate (2025)	Red Flag Price
Housekeeper (full-time)	$442-650/month	Under $400 (may be illegal) or over $800
Housekeeper (part-time)	$5-7/hour	Under $5 or over $10/hour
Gardener (weekly)	$40-80/visit	Over $120/visit for standard lot
Pool service (weekly)	$50-100/month	Over $200/month basic service
Property manager	10-15% gross rental	Over 20%

Construction and Repairs

Service	Fair Rate (2025)	Notes
General handyman	$15-25/hour	Plus materials
Skilled carpenter	$25-40/hour	Experienced
Plumber	$30-50/hour	Emergency rates higher
Electrician	$35-55/hour	Must be licensed
Painter	$15-25/hour	Depending on detail work

Important: These are guidelines. Rates vary by location (higher in tourist areas) and provider experience.

When to Consider Professional Property Management Services

Sometimes the answer isn't finding individual providers — it's having someone manage all of them for you.

You need property management if:

• You're an absentee owner visiting only a few times per year

• You're over 60 and tired of dealing with unreliable contractors

• You don't speak enough Spanish to manage providers effectively

• You've been burned by bad providers multiple times

• Your property is generating rental income

• You have complex maintenance needs (pool, garden, septic, etc.)

• 
  

What Professional Property Management Should Include:

Provider vetting and hiring:

• Background checks and reference verification

• License and insurance validation

• Negotiating fair rates on your behalf

Ongoing supervision:

• Regular property inspections

• Ensuring providers show up and complete work correctly

• Handling payments and documentation

Problem resolution:

• Dealing with no-shows, poor work, or disputes

• Finding replacement providers when needed

• Ensuring legal compliance

Communication:

• Regular reports (weekly or monthly)

• Photos documenting condition and work completed

• Immediate contact for emergencies

The investment: Professional property management typically costs 10-15% of rental income for rental properties, or $200-700/month for non-rental properties depending on size and needs.

The return: Peace of mind, protected property value, fair pricing, and no more dealing with flaky contractors.

Red Flags Specific to Hiring Domestic Help in Costa Rica

Household staff (maids, housekeepers, caretakers) require special considerations because they work in your private space and often have access when you're not home.

Additional Red Flags for Household Staff:

⚠️ Can't or won't provide proof of legal residency Many domestic workers in Costa Rica are Nicaraguan immigrants. You must verify they have legal permission to work or you face fines of 2-12 times the minimum salary.

⚠️ Refuses CAJA enrollment By law, all domestic employees must be registered with CAJA social security. If they refuse, they're either working illegally or planning to work for multiple employers improperly.

⚠️ No clear previous employment history Unlike contractors, household staff should be able to provide a clear history of previous employers and why they left each position.

⚠️ Uncomfortable with supervision or questions You need to be able to check their work, provide feedback, and ask questions. Defensiveness is a red flag.

⚠️ Brings friends/family without permission Your home is private. Anyone working there should come alone unless you've explicitly agreed otherwise.

Real-World Success Stories: What Proper Vetting Looks Like

Let me share what happens when you do this right.

Case Study 1: Robert's Gardener Nightmare → Solution

The problem: Robert, a 68-year-old retiree in Playa Flamingo, went through three gardeners in six months. Each started strong, then disappeared or did shoddy work. His half-acre property was becoming overgrown, attracting snakes and rodents.

What we did:

• Interviewed 5 candidates with neighborhood references

• Verified CAJA registration and insurance

• Conducted site visit with finalist

• Started with 4-week trial period

• Established clear weekly checklist with photos

The result: 13 months later, same gardener still shows up every Tuesday morning at 8 AM. Property looks better than when Robert moved in. Cost: $280/month — fair market rate.

Case Study 2: Patricia's Bathroom Renovation Success

The problem: Patricia needed a complete bathroom renovation in Tamarindo. She'd heard horror stories and was terrified of hiring the wrong contractor.

What we did:

• Sourced 3 contractors through verified referrals

• Reviewed recent job sites for each

• Checked licenses, insurance, CAJA compliance

• Negotiated detailed contract with payment milestones

• Weekly progress inspections with photos

The result: Completed in 5 weeks (vs. 4-week estimate — pretty good!). Budget: $8,500. Final cost: $8,200 (under budget). Quality: Excellent. Patricia actually referred this contractor to two friends.

Case Study 3: David's Property Management Relief

The problem: David, a 72-year-old living in Nosara, was exhausted managing his pool guy, gardener, housekeeper, and handyman while dealing with health issues. Communication was difficult, providers were inconsistent, and he was overpaying.

What we implemented:

• Vetted and replaced 3 of 4 providers

• Negotiated fair rates (saved 30% monthly)

• Established weekly inspection schedule

• Created WhatsApp group for all providers

• Monthly reports with photos to David's daughter in Florida

The result: David now pays $650/month for full property management. All providers show up reliably. His daughter has peace of mind. David focuses on his health and enjoying Costa Rica instead of chasing contractors.

Your Free Newsletter: Property Management Tips for Expats

Want weekly tips on maintaining your Costa Rica property, finding reliable providers, and avoiding expensive mistakes?

Subscribe to Our Property Management Newsletter

• Seasonal maintenance reminders (rainy season prep, etc.)

• Fair pricing updates as rates change

• Red flags and scam warnings specific to your area

• Vetted provider recommendations

• Legal updates affecting property owners

No fluff. No spam. Just practical advice from someone who's managed luxury properties.

Join 500+ expat homeowners who protect their investment with insider knowledge. Unsubscribe anytime.

Schedule Your Free Property Assessment & Provider Vetting Consultation

Tired of dealing with flaky contractors, overpriced services, and constant property headaches?

Let's Talk About Your Property Management Needs

During your free 30-minute consultation, we'll:

• Assess your current provider situation

• Identify vulnerabilities in your property maintenance

• Discuss fair pricing for your specific needs

• Review our provider vetting process

• Create a customized maintenance plan

What makes our provider vetting different:

• Complete background verification — References, licenses, insurance, legal status

• In-person interviews — We meet providers face-to-face and assess professionalism

• Work site visits — We inspect their current jobs to verify quality

• Ongoing monitoring — We supervise providers and ensure consistent quality

• Legal compliance — We handle all CAJA registration and labor law requirements

Real Results from Our Provider Vetting:

"After three terrible gardeners in a row, I was ready to let my property turn into a jungle. Tere found someone who's shown up every single week for 18 months. The relief is incredible." — Robert, Playa Flamingo

"The contractor Tere vetted completed my bathroom renovation on time and under budget. I didn't think that was possible in Costa Rica." — Patricia, Tamarindo

"Having someone who can actually communicate with my providers in Spanish and check their work has saved me thousands." — David, Nosara

Schedule Your Free Property Consultation

WhatsApp: +506 7075-5307

Email: info@expatseniorcr.com

Website: expatseniorcr.com

Because your Costa Rica property deserves better than flaky contractors and overpriced services.

Final Thoughts: Trust Your Gut

You know what? Sometimes you can't put your finger on exactly what's wrong, but something feels off about a provider.

Trust that feeling.

I've learned that gut instincts are usually right. If a provider makes you uncomfortable, gives you a bad vibe, or just doesn't feel trustworthy — even if you can't point to a specific red flag — listen to that.

There are too many good, reliable, honest providers in Costa Rica to settle for someone who makes you uneasy.

Your property, your peace of mind, and your wallet deserve better.

About the Author

Tere is a fully bilingual Costa Rican (Tica) with years of experience managing British Embassy diplomatic residences and luxury properties in Costa Rica. She founded Expat Senior Concierge to help property owners find reliable providers, maintain their homes to diplomatic standards, and avoid the costly mistakes that plague many expats. Her provider vetting system has helped dozens of homeowners finally get consistent, quality service.